Your Festive Numbers Aren't Final Yet
Every Indian D2C brand is writing its festive post-mortem this fortnight, and most of them are reading a gross number as if it were a result.
The revenue on your dashboard is awaiting returns resolution, RTO settlement, and a cohort whose repeat behaviour nobody can see for another ninety days. Some of what looks like a conclusion is a measurement that has not finished.
The Average Describes Almost Nobody
The headline figure doing the rounds is a 45% increase in D2C sales value, from ClickPost's analysis of more than 8 crore orders across nearly 400 brands.
Now the distribution, from ClickPost's fixed cohort of 200 brands that shipped more than 500 forward orders in both the 2025 and 2026 windows:
Share of brands | |
|---|---|
Grew shipments by more than 50% | Around one third |
Grew by more than 25% | Roughly one in two |
Median brand growth | ~19% |
Shrank by more than 25% | More than one in five |
So the widely quoted growth figure sits more than twice the median, and one in five brands went backwards by a quarter in the same season, paying the same festive ad prices.
If you are benchmarking against 45%, you are benchmarking against a number that describes almost nobody. The median is the more useful comparator, and the distribution is more useful still — because it tells you the season separated brands rather than lifting them uniformly.
Unicommerce's figures point the same way from a different angle: brand website orders grew 30% against 8% on marketplaces. The channel mattered more than the season did.
Your Revenue Number Is Gross
Festive revenue is booked at order placement. Returns resolve over the following weeks, in a different system, usually with no link back to the cohort that generated them.
Which means the number in your festive report is the top of a figure that is still settling — and the settlement runs on its own schedule, not your reporting calendar.
Three things are still outstanding on a report written this week: customer returns within the return window, RTO resolution on COD orders, and refunds processed against both.
The RTO Picture Is Genuinely Contested
Worth being careful here, because the most-quoted festive returns figure has a problem.
Unicommerce's India D2C Report 2026 is widely cited as finding that 58% of COD orders came back during the festive quarter, against under 15% for prepaid. That figure is doing a lot of work in a lot of post-mortems.
But the public summary does not state the denominator, and it describes the period variously as the festive season, the festive quarter and the festive peak. It is also unclear whether it counts failed deliveries, customer returns, or both. ClickPost's own write-up notes exactly this ambiguity.
Meanwhile ClickPost's 2026 data points the other way: failed delivery attempts fell from 22% to 21% of orders, and orders returned to sellers undelivered fell from 11% to 10%.
Both can be true. They are different cohorts, different denominators and possibly different definitions of "returned."
The practical instruction is to stop quoting either and measure your own. Your RTO rate, by payment method, for the festive cohort specifically, once the window closes. Our post on RTO as a measurement problem covers how to build that view.
Acquisition Cost Rose, and Not Evenly
Kearney estimates D2C customer acquisition cost rose 15–20% this season.
The segment split matters more than the headline. For mass-market brands, where average baskets declined around 3%, acquisition cost per rupee of sales rose roughly 19–24%. For premium brands, where baskets grew around 14%, the increase was only 1–5%.
So two brands could both report revenue growth this season while one improved its unit economics and the other degraded them — and nothing in a revenue figure distinguishes them.
Note also that ClickPost found GMV growing roughly 1.7 times faster than order volume, which means average order value rose across their sample. Whether your AOV rose or compressed is a question about your brand, not the season. Check it before assuming either.
The Cohort Question Nobody Can Answer Yet
The buyers you acquired on festive discount: will they come back at full price?
Nobody knows yet, including anyone publishing a festive report this month. A ninety-day repeat window on a cohort acquired in late October closes in late January.
This is the question that determines whether the season was good. A brand that acquired many customers cheaply into a cohort that never reorders has bought revenue, not growth — and for most categories, first orders are not where the profit sits.
The only useful thing to do now is tag the cohort so you can answer it later. Festive acquisition date, acquisition channel, discount applied, payment method. If that segmentation does not exist by the time January arrives, the question becomes unanswerable rather than merely unanswered.
Safe to Conclude Now vs Wait Until January
Safe to conclude now | Wait until January |
|---|---|
Order volume and traffic growth | Net revenue after returns and RTO |
Channel mix and where traffic came from | Whether the cohort repeats |
Conversion rate by segment, with the mix caveat | Whether acquisition cost was justified |
Site stability and technical performance | Contribution per acquired customer |
Payment mix shift | Whether discount depth was worth it |
Checkout and funnel defects you found | Which creative or channel produced better customers |
Qualitative findings — search queries, support tickets, stock-outs | Whether any variant tested during the window holds |
The left column is operational. It describes what happened mechanically and most of it is final.
The right column is commercial. It describes whether the season was worth running, and none of it has resolved.
A festive report that presents right-column conclusions from left-column data is doing what we have written about in how to read a CRO agency's monthly report — presenting observed movement as a validated result.
One more for the right column: anything you tested during the window. Festive traffic is a temporarily different population, which is covered in why your festive-season test results will lie to you.
Three Numbers to Diarise for January
Put these in a calendar now, with an owner.
1. Net revenue after returns and RTO. Festive gross revenue minus customer returns minus RTO, for the festive cohort specifically. This is the number that should have been in the post-mortem and could not be.
2. Second-order rate for the festive cohort, at 90 days. What proportion of festive-acquired customers bought again. Compare against your non-festive cohort for the same window. This is the single number that tells you whether the season built the business or borrowed from it.
3. Contribution per acquired customer. Net revenue minus COGS, shipping, payment processing, discount and reverse logistics, divided by customers acquired. Split by payment method — the prepaid and COD economics will differ substantially, as covered in prepaid conversion as a CRO problem.
If any of these cannot be calculated in January because the cohort was never tagged, that is this week's job rather than January's.
The Short Version
Report what is final. Diarise what is not. And compare yourself against the median rather than the headline, because the distribution this season was wide enough that the average describes a brand that may not exist.
For where your numbers sit against the category more broadly, see our Indian D2C conversion benchmarks.
Writing a festive post-mortem and unsure which numbers are final? Get a CRO audit from FunnelFreaks.